Study Details

Study Title: Safety Effects of Different Driveway Types Defined in Highway Safety Manual

Authors: Williamson et al.

Publication Date: 2018

Abstract: The Highway Safety Manual (HSM) categorizes driveways into commercial, industrial-institutional, or residential, which are further classified as major or minor driveways based on the number of parking spaces. However, the safety effects of different driveway types are not clearly defined or studied. The objective of this research was to quantify the safety impacts of different types of driveways by and developing crash modification factors (CMFs) when converting one type of driveway into another one. Crash data was obtained in eighteen randomly selected cities throughout Illinois. A total of 1,176 crashes were collected at 1,118 different driveways during a five-year period from 2005 to 2009. The driveway types analyzed in this study include commercial, industrial-institutional, and residential; additionally, commercial types with drive-through were separated during the analysis due to the higher observed crash rate. Roadway types included two-lane undivided (2U), two-lane with a two-way left turn lane (TWLTL) (3T), four-lane undivided (4U), and four lanes with a TWLTL (5T) and they were all located along state maintained routes. Using recommended statistical methods by HSM, 39 crash prediction models were developed for the different types of driveways on four different types of roadways. Based on the crash prediction models, 162 CMFs were developed identifying the safety impact of converting different driveway types along different roadway types in urban areas. The results of this study can help transportation engineers, planners, and safety engineers to better understand potential safety effects of different driveway types under different roadway and land use environments.

Study Citation: Williamson, M.R., H. Zhou, and R. Fries. "Safety Effects of Different Driveway Types Defined in Highway Safety Manual". Presented at the 97th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Paper No. 18-01220, Washington, D.C., (2018).

Study Report: Download the Study Report Document


CMFs Associated With This Study

Category: Access management

Countermeasure: Change driveway type

CMF CRF(%)QualityCrash TypeCrash SeverityRoadway TypeArea Type
0.07932 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.237-123.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.49650.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.51-3512 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.51-3512 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.016-101.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.31568.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
14.295-1329.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
6.39-5392 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.17-2172 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.45654.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.12987.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.194-119.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.28271.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
7.78-6782 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.546-254.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.56243.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.16842 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.78-782 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
6.248-524.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
6.248-524.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.51-2512 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.53546.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.18181.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.869-86.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.33866.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
5.526-452.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.956-195.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.45554.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.22377.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.05194.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.197-119.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.48951.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.11288.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.493-349.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.045-104.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.35-3352 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
19.545-1854.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
8.894-789.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.35-3352 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.69130.91 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.15884.21 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.447-44.71 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.22977.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
6.315-531.51 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.365-336.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.21378.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.22777.31 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.696-369.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.9396.11 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.411-341.11 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.065-6.51 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.67132.91 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.47852.21 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.491-49.11 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.71328.71 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.092-109.21 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.403-40.31 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.47452.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.22177.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.111-111.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.46753.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.521-352.11 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.142-114.21 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.34365.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.10989.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.919-191.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.31768.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
9.193-819.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.15-2152 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.67832.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.13586.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.474-47.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.19980.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
7.418-641.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
5.031-403.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.47852.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.09390.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.093-109.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.19680.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
10.702-970.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.403-40.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.44755.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.22277.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban

Category:Roadway

Countermeasure: Change urban or suburban roadway cross-section

CMF CRF(%)QualityCrash TypeCrash SeverityRoadway TypeArea Type
3.074-207.41 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.61638.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.855-185.51 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.894-89.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.21678.41 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.35651 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.66333.71 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.5502 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.497-349.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.076-107.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2-1002 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
8.994-799.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.152-315.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.22277.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.11188.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.46253.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.324-132.41 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
13.989-1298.91 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
01001 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.43572 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
6.02-5021 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
01001 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.07192.91 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.16683.41 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
01001 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.427-42.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.019-101.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.202-120.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.70129.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.415-41.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.543-54.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.49550.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.70729.32 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.091-9.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.826-182.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.816-181.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.189-218.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.35464.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.9960.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.128-12.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.35564.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.004-0.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.189-218.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.769-76.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.735-73.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.168-216.82 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.56543.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.9811.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.791-79.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.57642.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.02-22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.826-82.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianONot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.744-74.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.837-183.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.641-164.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.57442.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.627-62.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.515-51.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.35364.72 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.61538.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.149-114.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.33-2332 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.834-183.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.46553.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.55-552 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.319-31.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.3702 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.64535.52 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.85114.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.171-117.12 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
3.994-299.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
2.31-1312 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.46153.92 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.84-842 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.064-6.42 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.25752 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.54445.62 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
0.57842.22 StarsAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianAllNot specifiedUrban and suburban
1.623-62.31 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban
4.634-363.41 StarAngle,Fixed object,Left turn,Rear end,Sideswipe,Vehicle/bicycle,Vehicle/pedestrianK,A,B,CNot specifiedUrban and suburban